ops: forwarding through a downstream WireGuard terminator is free
FortiOS has no WireGuard, so any WireGuard site-to-site has to terminate behind the edge, and ana-wg already fills that role. The earlier 767 Mbit/s figure was taken with traffic terminating on that box, which left the forwarding case unmeasured and overstated what a real deployment would see. Measured properly, transit from NH3 through the tunnel and onward to ana-docker returns 763.8 Mbit/s on one stream and 790.4 across eight, so the forwarding hop costs nothing and the full threefold gain over IPsec survives. The container uses around a fifth of four cores at that rate, against the UniFi gateway spending a third of its own four to move a third as much. The note records what still needs deciding rather than presenting this as ready to build: Anaheim hosts have to route to the terminator directly or pay a hairpin through the edge, which was not measured; the terminator introduces a failure mode the edge did not have, with a fallback route as the mitigation; and the NH3 end needs its own terminator, where a Linux host matches the measured figure while the existing UniFi WireGuard server would likely land lower. The test tunnel, its peer and the temporary route were all removed.
This commit is contained in:
@@ -444,3 +444,60 @@ UDM network object verified **byte-identical** to its pre-test snapshot
|
||||
left as `aes256-sha1 aes256gcm aes128-sha1` — a permissive superset; the peer
|
||||
offers only aes256 so the extra entries are inert, but **narrowing it back to
|
||||
`aes256-sha1` is one line** if the looser list is unwanted.
|
||||
|
||||
---
|
||||
|
||||
## FOLLOW-UP 4 (2026-08-23): a downstream WireGuard terminator costs nothing to forward through
|
||||
|
||||
Operator's point: FortiOS has no WireGuard, so a WireGuard site-to-site must
|
||||
terminate on a box *behind* the edge. Correct — and `ana-wg` (LXC, CT 113 on
|
||||
pfi-pve, 10.250.50.252) already is that box.
|
||||
|
||||
**This closes a gap in FOLLOW-UP 3.** That 767 Mbit/s figure was measured with
|
||||
traffic terminating *on* ana-wg. Real traffic must be forwarded onward to other
|
||||
Anaheim hosts, which was never measured. Now it is:
|
||||
|
||||
| topology | 1 stream | 8 streams |
|
||||
|---|---|---|
|
||||
| IPsec, FortiGate ↔ UDM (today) | 245 Mbit/s | 692 Mbit/s |
|
||||
| WG terminating **on** ana-wg | 767 Mbit/s | 763 Mbit/s |
|
||||
| **WG transit: nh3 → wg → ana-wg → forward → ana-docker** | **763.8 Mbit/s** | **790.4 Mbit/s** |
|
||||
|
||||
**Forwarding through the LXC is free** (763.8 vs 767). The downstream-VM
|
||||
architecture delivers the full 3.1× single-stream for real transit traffic, not
|
||||
just for traffic landing on the tunnel box.
|
||||
|
||||
ana-wg while forwarding 764 Mbit/s: **~22% busy across 4 cores** (77.8% idle),
|
||||
so roughly 0.9 cores. Note `/proc/loadavg` inside this LXC reports the *host's*
|
||||
load, not the container's — do not read it as ana-wg's own. For contrast the
|
||||
UDM burns 35.4% of its 4 cores to move 240 Mbit/s, so ana-wg has ample headroom.
|
||||
|
||||
### Design consequences of terminating downstream — the parts that need decisions
|
||||
|
||||
1. **Anaheim hosts must route to ana-wg, not to the FortiGate.** The 763.8
|
||||
figure was obtained with an explicit `10.30.10.200/32 via 10.250.50.252`
|
||||
route on ana-docker. Without that, a host sends 10.100.0.0/16 to its default
|
||||
gateway (ana-gw), which routes it back out the *same* interface to ana-wg — a
|
||||
LAN hairpin crossing the FortiGate twice. **The hairpin variant was NOT
|
||||
measured.** Options: DHCP option 121 pushing the route fleet-wide, a dedicated
|
||||
transit VLAN for ana-wg, or accept the hairpin.
|
||||
2. **New single point of failure.** Today site-to-site dies only when the edge
|
||||
dies, which is total anyway. A downstream terminator fails independently.
|
||||
Mitigation: keep the IPsec tunnel configured as a higher-metric fallback
|
||||
route so it takes over when ana-wg is down.
|
||||
3. **ana-wg is an LXC on pfi-pve**, so its ~0.9 cores and NIC traffic land on the
|
||||
hypervisor shared with the rest of the Anaheim VMs.
|
||||
4. **The NH3 end needs a terminator too**, and there are two shapes:
|
||||
- **Linux VM at NH3** (nh3-dev or a dedicated VM on nh3-pve) — this is what
|
||||
was measured: **764 Mbit/s**.
|
||||
- **NH3 UDM's existing WireGuard server** (`PFI-NH3-WG`, wireguard-server on
|
||||
UDP 31337) accepting ana-wg as a peer — plausible but **untested**, and
|
||||
UniFi's WireGuard shows a per-flow penalty (557 Mbit/s single-stream on
|
||||
Site Magic), so expect ~557 rather than 764. Still 2.3× today.
|
||||
|
||||
### Standing recommendation
|
||||
|
||||
Worth doing, but it is **a project, not a config tweak** — routing, failover and
|
||||
policy all need deciding. The cheap wins remain available meanwhile and are
|
||||
independent: `nconnect=8` on NFS mounts (approved by brokkr-smithy-dev, pending
|
||||
the FortiGate work settling) and AES-128 for ~20%.
|
||||
|
||||
Reference in New Issue
Block a user