Files
esh-pfi-infrastructure/services
vh ce09ac4fa6 test(gen-seat): add a real vision battery — orcarouter scores 7/8
surface_test.py's vision check is one image and one word. It proves the tower
loads; it does not prove the tower works. This battery uses generated images with
known ground truth so every answer is objectively gradeable.

Against orcarouter NVFP4-mixed on the `gen` alias:

  T1  OCR, 5 lines incl. one at 18px          PASS  all 5 exact
  T2  counting + attribute binding            PASS  7 circles / 3 triangles / 1 square
  T3  bar chart, 6 values + max/min           PASS  6/6 exact
  T4b occlusion, star behind rectangle        PASS
  T4c aspect ratio of a 160x140 rectangle     FAIL  called it taller than wide
  T5  two images, which has text              PASS
  T6  four images, the seat's cap             PASS  all four named
  T7  five images, one over the cap           PASS  rejected with HTTP 400

No <think> leak on any vision call.

The single miss is fine-grained relative-dimension estimation on a near-square
shape, and it reproduced across two runs (the longer T4 called the same rectangle
"equal width and height"). Counting, OCR, chart values and occlusion ordering are
all solid, so this is a precise-geometry weakness, not a broken tower. Recorded so
nobody builds a feature on this model judging relative sizes.

T7 earns its place separately: it confirms the per-prompt image cap fails loudly
with a 400 rather than silently dropping the extra image.
2026-08-21 01:52:33 -07:00
..