Second bench window, operator-authorised after an initial decline and reversal.
Stock BF16 against the llmfan46 abliterated BF16: same precision, same pinned
upstream template, same 192 items, CoT off. Abliteration was the only axis that
moved, which is what the previous run could not claim.
Net core cost is 0.6 points — but the headline understates what happened.
Capability MOVED rather than degraded: five items lost on contradiction
detection, four gained on spatial composition, nearly cancelling. A gain was not
predicted by anyone, least of all on that axis.
The decision this was authorised to settle: llmfan46 stands as the trainee base.
No case for re-staging on TrevorJS at KL 0.09 over 0.6 points — the KL gap
between the builds is smaller than the gap this measurement failed to find.
Both limits recorded rather than buried, per brokkr-smithy-dev: the swings are
~5 and ~4 items at n=32, so the -15.6/+12.5 percentages read more precisely than
the measurement supports and only marginals were run; and this says nothing
about quantization, because the stock-NVFP4 T2 figure came from n=16 against
n=32 here — different item counts mean different item sets, so that comparison
is n-confounded and is not being made.
Turnaround was five minutes rather than fifteen because the gemma4-trainee-bench
stack already existed — itself the residue of debugging a 35-restart crash-loop
caused by the production compose hardcoding --quantization compressed-tensors.
The fix outlasted the incident.
gen restored and verified through the gateway; char-rp remains down deliberately;
bench stack env reset to the heretic base for the post-tune gate.
vh
5415fd4b30