svos-dev observed that three instances of the same shape turned up between two
agents in one night and that it is starting to look like a characteristic failure
rather than a coincidence. Collecting all nine from today, because the class is more
useful than any instance.
The shape is a check that reads the input to a transformation and gets reported as
if it read the output - or more generally, the instrument answering instead of the
system, in a form shaped exactly like a real answer. What makes it expensive is not
that things break but that the broken state is indistinguishable from a legitimate
one, so it passes review and is found later by accident. Every one of the nine
passed a check.
The tell is stated so it can be recognised prospectively: whenever 'broken' and
'legitimately empty, absent or off' produce the same output, the cheap check cannot
tell them apart by construction.
Remedies that actually worked today: measure the output rather than the input;
positive controls, since a method that has only ever passed cannot tell you it is
not blind; true-negative controls, because two apparent failures in the
secrets-broker test were names I had invented and would have been read as a partial
fix; refuse to emit the ambiguous value, which was the real fix rather than the
lock; and do not declare victory on a plausible fix, which is the only reason the
session-establishment root cause was found at all.
vh
af8d6df387