Vuong Hoang
e8eb1594d9
1,200 generations across five arms. ckpt300 (epoch 0.652) is the best arm in the
run on every axis that resolves:
VOICE +0.177 at 3.2x its pairwise floor (primary), +0.128 at 2.8x with
every punctuation mark stripped. Best point estimate AND best
margin of any arm, spread 0.055/0.038 with no outlier seed.
MEMORISATION 0.12 against real unseen McCarthy's own 0.12 -- identical -- with
a longest match of 10 words against the author's coincidental 12.
All 31 matches read: stock grammar, names are the renamed
inventions, nothing protectable.
DAMAGE ran-on +0.12. Clears the operator's ratified v2 floor of 0.200 by
40%. FAILS AMENDMENT 3's self-imposed 0.100 bar by 0.02.
NOT SHIPPED, and the reason is the bar rather than the adapter. AMENDMENT 3 fixed
ran-on <= 0.100 before either new arm existed, precisely so a marginal number could
not be talked into a ship, and shipping at 0.12 would make that pre-registration
theatre. But the bar's stated rationale was written against ckpt450's pass by 0.01
-- 5% of the threshold -- and ckpt300 clears by 40%. The number excludes a candidate
the reasoning does not. That is an operator call.
ckpt325/350/375 are on disk and one may sit under 0.100. They were deliberately NOT
gated: searching the checkpoint space until something clears is candidate-shopping,
the same family as threshold-shopping approached from the other side.
THREE CLAIMS FROM EARLIER THIS SESSION ARE REFUTED and are corrected in the record:
1. "The damage is flat across epochs and only rotates direction" -- FALSE. ran-on
is non-monotonic (0.38 -> 0.13 -> 0.20 -> 0.28 across epochs 0.49/0.65/0.98/
1.96) with a real minimum near 0.65, and ckpt225 is 48% out-of-band against
ckpt300's 35%.
2. "ckpt300 runs far too short, ckpt225 will clear ran-on by being short" -- FALSE
on both. ckpt225 runs LONG (median 127, 38% over-band) and is the worst arm in
the run. I generalised from SIX generations of one arm, which is the exact n=1
violation the measurement-discipline rule names, committed in the same breath
as a note about being careful.
3. The original "gate an earlier checkpoint, the overshoot may not have arrived
yet" recommendation was RIGHT. Retracting it an hour later on a three-arm read
was the error, not the recommendation.
What is true and unresolved by any checkpoint choice: 35% of ckpt300's generations
miss the 90-140 band against base's 11%, and in-band is 0.65 against 0.89. An
adapter that buys a voice and costs a third of the length compliance is a trade, not
a defect -- but it is the operator's trade to accept.
Raw artifacts for all five arms at scripts/mccarthy-corpus/gate-results/.
330 lines
14 KiB
Plaintext
330 lines
14 KiB
Plaintext
corpus (train split only): 548,202 words, 547,556 distinct 8-grams
|
|
[PASS] positive control: a corpus slice matches itself
|
|
|
|
161 matched run(s), longest 11 words. 74 carry a mid-run capital.
|
|
|
|
[ 11w] ckpt900 b31 seed=9012 ⚠ CAPS: Adam, Caleb, What
|
|
Toribio looked at Adam Caleb What do you want to do
|
|
[ 11w] ckpt900 b41 seed=5678 ⚠ CAPS: The
|
|
He looked at the old man The old man was watching
|
|
[ 10w] ckpt225 b3 seed=1234
|
|
He leaned back in his chair and looked at the
|
|
[ 10w] ckpt225 b21 seed=5678
|
|
he leaned back in the chair and crossed his legs
|
|
[ 10w] ckpt225 b35 seed=5678
|
|
he looked at the old man the old man was
|
|
[ 10w] ckpt225 b36 seed=9012 ⚠ CAPS: The
|
|
He looked at the boy The boy was looking at
|
|
[ 10w] ckpt225 b45 seed=5678
|
|
and took off his hat and put it on the
|
|
[ 10w] ckpt300 b23 seed=9012
|
|
looked at the wolf and he looked at the boy
|
|
[ 10w] ckpt300 b27 seed=9012 ⚠ CAPS: He
|
|
and put it in the pocket of his coat He
|
|
[ 10w] ckpt450 b9 seed=3456
|
|
leaned back in his chair and looked at the boy
|
|
[ 10w] ckpt450 b21 seed=3456
|
|
he sat with his elbows on his knees and looked
|
|
[ 10w] ckpt450 b29 seed=1234
|
|
he looked at the wolf and he looked at him
|
|
[ 10w] ckpt900 b9 seed=3456
|
|
The old man drank the last of his coffee and
|
|
[ 10w] ckpt900 b21 seed=5678
|
|
sat leaning with his elbows on the table and his
|
|
[ 10w] ckpt900 b37 seed=1234 ⚠ CAPS: Toribio, I, Adam, Caleb, I
|
|
said Toribio I dont know said Adam Caleb I aint
|
|
[ 10w] ckpt900 b41 seed=3456
|
|
he looked at the wolf and he looked at the
|
|
[ 10w] ckpt900 b46 seed=9012
|
|
them in his hand and looked at them and then
|
|
[ 10w] ckpt900 b49 seed=3456 ⚠ CAPS: Adam, Caleb, Toribio
|
|
He looked at Adam Caleb and he looked at Toribio
|
|
[ 9w] ckpt225 b6 seed=3456 ⚠ CAPS: He
|
|
The man looked at him He looked at the
|
|
[ 9w] ckpt225 b28 seed=1234 ⚠ CAPS: What
|
|
I dont know What are you goin to do
|
|
[ 9w] ckpt225 b28 seed=1234 ⚠ CAPS: What
|
|
I dont know What are you goin to do
|
|
[ 9w] ckpt225 b37 seed=3456 ⚠ CAPS: Adam, Caleb
|
|
looked at Adam Caleb and he looked at the
|
|
[ 9w] ckpt225 b45 seed=5678
|
|
took off his hat and set it on the
|
|
[ 9w] ckpt225 b49 seed=1234
|
|
and picked up his hat and put it on
|
|
[ 9w] ckpt225 b53 seed=9012
|
|
What do you want me to do with her
|
|
[ 9w] ckpt300 b7 seed=5678 ⚠ CAPS: Adam, Caleb, Adam, Caleb, Colton
|
|
looked at Adam Caleb Adam Caleb looked at Colton
|
|
[ 9w] ckpt300 b25 seed=5678 ⚠ CAPS: They
|
|
They looked at him They looked at each other
|
|
[ 9w] ckpt300 b44 seed=9012
|
|
and wiped his mouth on the back of his
|
|
[ 9w] ckpt300 b45 seed=3456
|
|
took off his hat and set it on the
|
|
[ 9w] ckpt300 b52 seed=5678
|
|
He took off his hat and put it on
|
|
[ 9w] ckpt450 b7 seed=1234 ⚠ CAPS: What
|
|
I dont know What are you goin to do
|
|
[ 9w] ckpt450 b7 seed=9012
|
|
He reached into his pocket and took out the
|
|
[ 9w] ckpt450 b11 seed=1234 ⚠ CAPS: What
|
|
I dont know What are you goin to do
|
|
[ 9w] ckpt450 b22 seed=3456
|
|
He got up and went into the bathroom and
|
|
[ 9w] ckpt450 b30 seed=5678 ⚠ CAPS: He
|
|
He turned and looked at the boy He was
|
|
[ 9w] ckpt450 b35 seed=1234 ⚠ CAPS: What
|
|
I dont know What are you goin to do
|
|
[ 9w] ckpt450 b47 seed=5678 ⚠ CAPS: The
|
|
He looked at the old man The old man
|
|
[ 9w] ckpt450 b47 seed=5678 ⚠ CAPS: The
|
|
He looked at the old man The old man
|
|
[ 9w] ckpt450 b48 seed=1234 ⚠ CAPS: What
|
|
I dont know What are you goin to do
|
|
[ 9w] ckpt450 b49 seed=3456
|
|
he was sitting with his back to the wall
|
|
[ 9w] ckpt450 b53 seed=3456
|
|
looked at the wolf and he looked at the
|
|
[ 9w] ckpt450 b55 seed=3456
|
|
and took out a cigarette and lit it and
|
|
[ 9w] ckpt900 b4 seed=1234
|
|
in one hand and the shotgun in the other
|
|
[ 9w] ckpt900 b6 seed=9012
|
|
and held it out and the boy took it
|
|
[ 9w] ckpt900 b15 seed=5678
|
|
on the far side of the road and he
|
|
[ 9w] ckpt900 b26 seed=5678
|
|
and he stood with his hat in his hand
|
|
[ 9w] ckpt900 b28 seed=3456 ⚠ CAPS: I
|
|
I dont know what you re talkin about I
|
|
[ 9w] ckpt900 b31 seed=5678
|
|
The sun had set and it was growing dark
|
|
[ 9w] ckpt900 b40 seed=1234 ⚠ CAPS: What
|
|
I dont know What are you goin to do
|
|
[ 9w] ckpt900 b42 seed=1234 ⚠ CAPS: The
|
|
He looked at the boy The boy was sitting
|
|
[ 9w] ckpt900 b47 seed=3456 ⚠ CAPS: He
|
|
man looked at him He looked at the horse
|
|
[ 9w] ckpt900 b48 seed=5678 ⚠ CAPS: I
|
|
I dont know he said I dont know how
|
|
[ 9w] ckpt900 b51 seed=9012 ⚠ CAPS: I, I
|
|
shook his head I dont know he said I
|
|
[ 9w] ckpt900 b59 seed=9012 ⚠ CAPS: He
|
|
The man looked at him He looked at the
|
|
[ 8w] base b53 seed=1234 ⚠ CAPS: The
|
|
looked at the old man The old man
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt225 b2 seed=9012 ⚠ CAPS: He
|
|
The man looked at the judge He looked
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt225 b10 seed=9012
|
|
and came around to the front of the
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt225 b11 seed=1234 ⚠ CAPS: What
|
|
I dont know What are you goin to
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt225 b17 seed=1234 ⚠ CAPS: He
|
|
looked at the wolf He looked at the
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt225 b19 seed=9012 ⚠ CAPS: I, Army, I
|
|
When I got out of the Army I
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt225 b20 seed=1234
|
|
there aint nothin to be done about it
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt225 b22 seed=3456
|
|
He took his handkerchief from his pocket and
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt225 b27 seed=1234
|
|
leaned back in his chair and looked at
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt225 b27 seed=1234 ⚠ CAPS: The
|
|
looked at the old man The old man
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt225 b27 seed=5678 ⚠ CAPS: The
|
|
looked at the old man The old man
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt225 b31 seed=9012 ⚠ CAPS: He
|
|
turned and walked back to the house He
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt225 b34 seed=9012 ⚠ CAPS: It
|
|
and turned it in his hand It was
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt225 b39 seed=1234 ⚠ CAPS: He
|
|
and looked at him He looked at the
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt225 b51 seed=9012 ⚠ CAPS: I
|
|
shook his head I dont know he said
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt225 b52 seed=5678 ⚠ CAPS: He
|
|
She looked at him He looked at the
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt225 b52 seed=9012 ⚠ CAPS: He
|
|
He sat there for a long time He
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt225 b53 seed=1234
|
|
What are you goin to do with her
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt225 b53 seed=9012 ⚠ CAPS: He
|
|
looked at the wolf He looked at the
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt225 b53 seed=9012 ⚠ CAPS: He
|
|
looked at the wolf He looked at the
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt225 b54 seed=5678
|
|
and after a while he rose and walked
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt225 b54 seed=3456
|
|
the road and he looked at the boy
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt225 b59 seed=9012 ⚠ CAPS: You
|
|
I know who you are he said You
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt300 b1 seed=1234
|
|
He was naked to the waist and he
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt300 b2 seed=9012 ⚠ CAPS: He
|
|
He turned and looked at the boy He
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt300 b6 seed=5678
|
|
and laid it on the ground and he
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt300 b6 seed=3456 ⚠ CAPS: The
|
|
and looked at the boy The boy was
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt300 b8 seed=5678
|
|
looked at the woman and he looked at
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt300 b9 seed=3456
|
|
on the table and pushed back his chair
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt300 b12 seed=5678 ⚠ CAPS: The
|
|
He looked at the boy The boy looked
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt300 b12 seed=5678
|
|
He looked at the boy and he looked
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt300 b13 seed=5678 ⚠ CAPS: The
|
|
and looked at the boy The boy was
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt300 b21 seed=5678 ⚠ CAPS: He
|
|
and set it down again He looked at
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt300 b23 seed=9012
|
|
at the wolf and he looked at the
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt300 b30 seed=9012
|
|
riders on the road behind them and they
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt300 b31 seed=9012 ⚠ CAPS: Adam, Caleb
|
|
Toribio and Adam Caleb looked at each other
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt300 b34 seed=3456
|
|
and slung it over his shoulder and stepped
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt300 b45 seed=9012
|
|
with the heel of his hand and turned
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt300 b48 seed=9012 ⚠ CAPS: I
|
|
I dont know he said I dont know
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt300 b49 seed=3456
|
|
picked him up and swung him onto his
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt300 b50 seed=3456
|
|
looked at the woman and he looked at
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt300 b52 seed=9012 ⚠ CAPS: He
|
|
He sat there for a long time He
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt300 b53 seed=1234
|
|
What are you goin to do with her
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt300 b53 seed=1234
|
|
What are you goin to do with her
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt300 b53 seed=9012 ⚠ CAPS: He
|
|
looked at the wolf He looked at the
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt300 b56 seed=5678
|
|
and leaned back in the chair and sat
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt300 b57 seed=1234
|
|
He put on his hat and went out
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt450 b2 seed=9012
|
|
He looked at the man and then he
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt450 b6 seed=3456
|
|
He looked at the boy and he looked
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt450 b10 seed=5678
|
|
and put the key in the door and
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt450 b10 seed=9012
|
|
He put the key in the ignition and
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt450 b12 seed=3456 ⚠ CAPS: The
|
|
said The boy turned and looked at him
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt450 b22 seed=5678
|
|
it in the palm of his hand and
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt450 b22 seed=5678
|
|
it and put it in his pocket and
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt450 b25 seed=1234 ⚠ CAPS: They, What
|
|
he said They looked at each other What
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt450 b25 seed=3456
|
|
and wiped his forehead with the back of
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt450 b28 seed=1234
|
|
I dont know what you re talkin about
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt450 b30 seed=9012
|
|
and unscrewed the cap and drank and screwed
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt450 b35 seed=5678 ⚠ CAPS: He
|
|
looked at him He shook his head and
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt450 b46 seed=3456
|
|
He turned it over and looked at the
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt450 b47 seed=1234
|
|
He sat with his elbows on his knees
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt450 b51 seed=5678 ⚠ CAPS: After, I
|
|
didnt answer After a while he said I
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt450 b52 seed=9012 ⚠ CAPS: He
|
|
He sat there for a long time He
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt450 b53 seed=3456
|
|
He looked at the old man and he
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt450 b56 seed=3456
|
|
he stood and put on his hat and
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt900 b2 seed=3456 ⚠ CAPS: He
|
|
He looked at them He looked at the
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt900 b4 seed=5678 ⚠ CAPS: He
|
|
there was no one in the room He
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt900 b9 seed=1234
|
|
for him to say something but he didnt
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt900 b10 seed=3456
|
|
and got out and walked down to the
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt900 b12 seed=3456 ⚠ CAPS: The
|
|
said The boy turned and looked at him
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt900 b13 seed=3456
|
|
He stepped back and looked out the door
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt900 b17 seed=1234
|
|
What are you goin to do with her
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt900 b17 seed=1234
|
|
What are you goin to do with her
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt900 b17 seed=3456
|
|
The boy sat holding the wolf by the
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt900 b23 seed=1234 ⚠ CAPS: The, He
|
|
said The boy looked at the wolf He
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt900 b23 seed=9012 ⚠ CAPS: He
|
|
man looked at him He looked at the
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt900 b27 seed=3456 ⚠ CAPS: He
|
|
man looked at him He looked at the
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt900 b27 seed=3456
|
|
He put the cigarette in his mouth and
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt900 b28 seed=3456
|
|
and he looked at it and he looked
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt900 b30 seed=5678
|
|
at the boy and he looked at the
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt900 b31 seed=3456 ⚠ CAPS: What
|
|
he said What do you want to do
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt900 b34 seed=5678
|
|
walked around the front of the truck and
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt900 b34 seed=9012
|
|
He walked out into the road and stood
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt900 b34 seed=3456
|
|
He walked out to the edge of the
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt900 b35 seed=3456 ⚠ CAPS: The
|
|
looked at the old man The old man
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt900 b35 seed=3456 ⚠ CAPS: She
|
|
her She s all right the boy said
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt900 b38 seed=9012
|
|
with the heel of his hand and looked
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt900 b39 seed=1234 ⚠ CAPS: I
|
|
What are you doin he said I thought
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt900 b39 seed=1234
|
|
and walked out and stood in the door
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt900 b39 seed=5678 ⚠ CAPS: Caleb, No
|
|
Adam Caleb shook his head No he said
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt900 b41 seed=1234 ⚠ CAPS: He
|
|
the road He turned and looked back at
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt900 b43 seed=1234
|
|
They were already out of sight of the
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt900 b44 seed=5678 ⚠ CAPS: He
|
|
on the pommel of the saddle He looked
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt900 b46 seed=1234
|
|
and put the key in his pocket and
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt900 b47 seed=3456 ⚠ CAPS: He
|
|
He leaned back in the chair He looked
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt900 b47 seed=3456
|
|
at the boy and he looked at the
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt900 b48 seed=5678 ⚠ CAPS: I, I
|
|
said I dont know I dont know how
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt900 b48 seed=5678
|
|
He looked at the boy and he looked
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt900 b49 seed=5678
|
|
about a third of the way down the
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt900 b50 seed=3456
|
|
and put it on and looked toward the
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt900 b51 seed=9012
|
|
wiped his mouth with the back of his
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt900 b52 seed=9012
|
|
He looked in the rearview mirror but he
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt900 b52 seed=3456 ⚠ CAPS: He
|
|
He looked out the window He looked at
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt900 b53 seed=1234
|
|
What are you goin to do with her
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt900 b53 seed=9012 ⚠ CAPS: He
|
|
he turned and looked at the boy He
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt900 b53 seed=3456 ⚠ CAPS: What
|
|
he looked at the boy What do you
|
|
[ 8w] ckpt900 b54 seed=5678
|
|
they came up out of the trees and
|
|
|
|
⚠ READ THESE. The rate is not the finding; what is being reproduced is.
|