vh
d9cf486004
Skaldsong's requirement is beat-sentence in, paragraph out, stitchable. That is narrower than free-form continuation and it fails differently, so it was tested directly rather than assumed from the earlier prompt work. The adapted 4B carrier cannot do it. Ten prompt formats across three seeds each -- bare, paragraph-break, labelled, epigraph, one-shot, one-shot unlabelled, three-shot, "it happened in this way", "I remember the whole of it", and the letter prompt's label-and-begin move applied to a beat -- produced thirty samples and not one that reliably renders the beat. They drift, they frame, or they truncate. The cause is structural rather than a shortfall of the adapter: "write a paragraph about this sentence" is an instruction, and a completion model has no mechanism for "about". It continues the text it is handed. Two formats failed worse than drifting and leaked pretraining task data. The paragraph-break format emitted an NLI multiple-choice item, and label-begin emitted a grammar-correction exercise. A standalone sentence followed by a blank line looks exactly like a dataset entry, and style adaptation does not remove base-model task artifacts. The same five beats through the gen seat with a style instruction and no adapter landed all ten samples inside the requested 90 to 140 word band, every one on its beat, with no drift into a following scene. The voice, however, is generic literary pastiche -- abstract-noun-heavy, fond of aphoristic openers, and over-written -- rather than Brontë. Voice without direction against direction without voice. The product needs both, which makes rebuilding the corpus as instruction-response pairs on an instruct carrier the evidence-backed option rather than more prompt cleverness. This applies to Yarros identically, because the carrier question is orthogonal to the author, so the next corpus should not re-run this experiment. Stitching also has its own failure mode, shown in the booth's third panel: the paragraphs were generated independently and the point of view slides between them, so by the fourth beat the narrator is both watching the girl carry the animals and carrying them herself. A real stitcher has to feed prior paragraphs back as context, which means the instruction-pair corpus wants multi-paragraph continuity examples and not only isolated beat-to-paragraph pairs.
8 lines
444 B
JSON
8 lines
444 B
JSON
[
|
|
{"id":"b1","beat":"The stray dog came down the lane in the rain, his ribs showing through his coat."},
|
|
{"id":"b2","beat":"He found the calico kitten under the mill gate, too weak to cry."},
|
|
{"id":"b3","beat":"He licked her clean, and would not be driven off."},
|
|
{"id":"b4","beat":"The girl carried them both home in her apron."},
|
|
{"id":"b5","beat":"By morning the kitten slept against the dog's flank as if she had never been alone."}
|
|
]
|