lv-krakauer: PARKED — research is not a voice (operator, henge id 82)
Operator ruling: "he's a great writer because of his research, not because he has a strong identifiable voice." That reason is about the AUTHOR rather than the data, and it is the better of the two on the table -- the other being the unmeasurable fraction of quoted material. It also names a selection criterion this line did not have: ask whether there IS a voice worth adapting before investigating whether a clean corpus can be built. That question was never asked here. I surveyed the holdings, built the corpus, measured all fifteen containment pairs, and fixed three stripping defects the name guard caught -- all real work, none of it touching the thing that decided it. A voice adapter is worth its corpus-plus-training-plus-gate only when the target has a prose signature a reader could pick out blind. McCarthy: 0.0 quote marks per 10k against Hemingway's 838. Hemingway: spare declaratives, heavy unattributed dialogue. Brontë: periodic sentences built on semicolons and dashes. If that sentence is hard to write, the author is a park. Nothing is deleted. The corpus (126 units, 422,880 words) and the builder stay committed and re-runnable; the park entry records what exists, what was never started (D2), and what would unpark it -- a re-extraction preserving indentation and italics, which would fix the quoted- material problem but not the operator's objection. The builder's own docstring now carries a stop notice so a future session finds the reason at the artifact rather than only in memory.
This commit is contained in:
@@ -1,5 +1,20 @@
|
||||
"""D1 for lv-krakauer: build the corpus from the licensed Kvasir masters.
|
||||
|
||||
⛔⛔ PARKED 2026-09-17 — DO NOT CARRY THIS TO D2 WITHOUT A NEW OPERATOR RULING.
|
||||
henge id 82, slug `lv-krakauer-voice-adapter-corpus-built-parked`.
|
||||
|
||||
The operator's reason is about the AUTHOR, not the data, and it is the better of the two:
|
||||
*"he's a great writer because of his research, not because he has a strong identifiable
|
||||
voice."* A voice adapter is worth its corpus-plus-training-plus-gate only if the target has a
|
||||
prose signature a reader could pick out blind. Krakauer's excellence is reporting — access,
|
||||
research, structure — and an adapter cannot carry any of it. **That question should have been
|
||||
asked before any of the work below**; corpus quality was investigated first and the prior
|
||||
question skipped.
|
||||
|
||||
Everything here still runs and the corpus still builds clean. What would unpark it is a
|
||||
re-extraction of the four ebooks with indentation and italics preserved — which fixes the
|
||||
quoted-material problem described below but NOT the operator's objection.
|
||||
|
||||
Same record schema as the Brontë, Yarros, Hemingway and McCarthy builders, so entities.py,
|
||||
rename.py, leak_gate.py and the trainers run unchanged.
|
||||
|
||||
|
||||
Reference in New Issue
Block a user