diff --git a/persistent-memory.d/2026-09-15-silent-wrong-answer-pattern.md b/persistent-memory.d/2026-09-15-silent-wrong-answer-pattern.md index d53a525..36d6f11 100644 --- a/persistent-memory.d/2026-09-15-silent-wrong-answer-pattern.md +++ b/persistent-memory.d/2026-09-15-silent-wrong-answer-pattern.md @@ -132,9 +132,31 @@ immediately after `/clear`, before any other framing, and its Next steps read as mandate. A wrong one here is not a bad summary; it is a fresh session going and doing belayed work. +### Mechanism — it is `SYSTEM_PROMPT`, not the model + +`snapshot_handoff.py:75-107`. Three things compose: + +1. **`## Next steps` has no empty case.** `## Watch out for` gets an explicit escape + ("OMIT THIS WHOLE SECTION if the input carries no gotchas"); `## Resume here` gets one + ("If the input says nothing is in flight, say so plainly"). **`## Next steps` gets + neither**, while being told it is "A numbered list. Ordered, concrete". With nothing + in flight, the only action-shaped nouns left are the deferred items. +2. **The nothing-in-flight rule points straight at them** — "point at the most recent + open pointer it names" directs attention to the parked entries, which then get + promoted into Next steps. +3. **Nothing protects MODALITY.** "Invent nothing; every claim must trace to the input" + is satisfied — the items *are* in the input. Their *deferred-ness* is what got + dropped, and only identifiers are protected against restructuring. + +⭐ **The general lesson: the verbatim-identifier rule shows some input attributes must +survive restructuring untouched. Modality is one of them and nobody guarded it.** + **Mitigation until fixed: read the generated handoff before accepting it**, and invert any deferred item into an explicit *do NOT*. Both runs this session were corrected -in-session. Owner is the `/snapshot` skill (galdrabok); not reported yet. +in-session. **Reported to `galdrabok-dev` 2026-09-15** with both specimens, the mechanism +above and two proposed prompt changes (an empty-case escape for `## Next steps`; a rule +making deferred/parked/belayed items constraints rather than steps). +⚠ `galdrabok-dev` is `mode: pull` — no herald poke, so they see it on their next check. ⭐ Same family as everything above — the instrument produced a plausible artifact and the plausibility is exactly what makes it dangerous.