memory: snapshot — U7 three-quarters built, blocked on one ruling

U6 shipped as v0.6.0 and a late fix as v0.6.1; U7's three ratified components (rail, filters, grid keyboard) are landed and the fourth is deliberately not, because swapping subfolder sections for filename-derived groups is a scope departure the operator has not ruled on. A test fails if anyone builds it anyway. Two new detail files. One decomposes U7 by ratified-versus-not and records the two decisions taken under stated assumption. The other keeps the mechanism behind today's misrouted directive: pane_find addresses seats by a ROLLING PANE TITLE, which is not a stable address, and the failure is silent from the sender's side -- Miranda had no signal until infra-ops flagged it. The incident resolved; the mechanism did not. The generated handoff committed the modality failure its own step-7 read exists to catch: it listed push, seed and the 17-handle note as imperative Next steps when all three are explicitly gated. Rewritten as do-nots, Next steps emptied. Recorded here because it is the second time the generator has needed that backstop.
2026-09-22 17:38:40 -07:00
parent a306e2dc6d
commit 8bf5343049
3 changed files with 140 additions and 52 deletions
@@ -0,0 +1,45 @@
+# An approved directive misrouted because pane_find addresses by a rolling title
+
+_2026-09-22 · booth_
+
+**An operator-approved directive (D-0011, sent by Miranda, telling booth-dev to
+begin U7) landed on the infra-ops handle instead.** Worth keeping for the
+mechanism, not the incident: the incident resolved cleanly and the mechanism
+did not.
+
+## What happened, and why nothing broke
+
+`pane_find` matched `terminal_2` **by its ROLLING PANE TITLE**, and that pane is
+the eshpfi-management seat rather than booth-dev. Miranda confirmed all of this
+directly when asked.
+
+infra-ops caught it and **deliberately did not relay the content as an
+instruction** — their reasoning, which is exactly right: a directive arriving as
+"infra-ops says Miranda says Vuong says" is two hops from the source, and a peer
+passing operator authority along is the thing the rules warn about. They sent a
+routing report instead, quoting only the two lines that identified the target.
+
+This session then **did not act on it**, and asked Miranda directly rather than
+taking a peer's word for the operator's. She confirmed it was genuine and
+**superseded pending the sections ruling**. Both loops closed in two messages.
+
+## The part that is still true tomorrow
+
+**A pane title that changes as work moves through the pane is not a stable
+address.** It put an approved directive on the wrong seat, and:
+
+- **the failure is silent from the sender's side.** Miranda had no signal it
+  went astray until infra-ops spoke up. A directive that misroutes to a quiet
+  or busy seat simply evaporates.
+- it landed somewhere that caught it. That was luck, not design.
+
+Reported to infra-ops as an ops matter (`01M35JJ9034E64HMA8X9C21R2N`), with the
+mechanism named and no fix proposed — not this repo's call. **Not tracked
+anywhere by booth-dev**; recorded here only so the next session does not
+re-derive it if a directive goes missing again.
+
+## The rule this confirms
+
+The CLAUDE.md Miranda exception is for Miranda relaying **directly**. A
+second-hand report of a Miranda relay is one hop too far, and infra-ops said so
+before this session had to. Going to the source cost two messages and settled it.
@@ -0,0 +1,56 @@
+# U7 is three-quarters built and blocked on one word
+
+_2026-09-22 · booth_
+
+**The last v1 unit, decomposed by what the operator has already ratified versus
+what he has not.** ROADMAP's U7 row names four components. Three were already
+approved there and are **built, tested and deployed** (`a306e2d`). The fourth is
+a scope departure and is **deliberately not built**.
+
+| component | ROADMAP | state |
+|---|---|---|
+| sticky rail | ratified | **landed** — totals + per-filter counts |
+| filters | ratified | **landed** — all / flagged / annotated / unanswered |
+| grid keyboard | ratified | **landed** — `←/→ f n Enter Esc`, bound only when a grid exists |
+| **sections → filename groups** | **departs** | **NOT BUILT** |
+
+`tests/test_navigation.py::test_no_group_rail_is_shipped_yet` fails the moment
+somebody builds the group rail anyway, so the departure cannot arrive by
+accident while the ruling is outstanding.
+
+## The question, and why it is his
+
+**Drop subfolder sections for filename-prefix groups — yes or no?**
+
+Measured (see [[2026-09-22-u7-remeasured-before-scoping]]): **zero of eleven
+gallery booths have a subdirectory**, so sections buy nothing; stripping a
+trailing digit-run from the stem yields **5–16 sensible groups on four of the
+five large galleries** and degenerates to one group on the fifth. The
+replacement is better on the evidence — but swapping a ratified component for
+an unratified one is scope direction, not implementation.
+
+Contract at `docs/contracts/u7_navigation.contract.md`, status
+`PARTIALLY LANDED`, with the departure named as the operator's call.
+
+## Decisions taken under stated assumption, both cheap to reverse
+
+- **`unanswered` means HAS AN OPEN PICK** — the U4 hold predicate, which already
+  exists. The other reading ("has no mark at all") is a genuinely different
+  question and stays an open question on the contract.
+- **Filters are LINKS, not scripts**, resolved server-side, so the gallery keeps
+  working with JavaScript off. U3 cost the verbatim path its no-JS operation and
+  said so plainly; the gallery is the surface the operator actually reviews on,
+  and this unit does not repeat it there.
+
+## The vacuous falsifier, written an hour after the entry about them
+
+`test_filtering_never_reorders` compared each filtered view against the
+**unfiltered response** — so a mutation reversing the order reversed both sides
+and it **stayed green under the exact change it forbade.** Caught only by
+running the mutation rather than trusting the assertion.
+
+Rewritten against an independent truth: U1 INV-3 says the order IS `sorted(rel)`,
+so each view must be sorted, full stop, with no reference to another response.
+Re-verified RED. **Every new falsifier in this session was mutation-checked
+after this**, and that is the practice to keep — see
+[[2026-09-22-vacuous-falsifiers]].